How it Works
with no additives
or artificial preservatives, ever.
We start with pure, healthy ingredients.
Organic flour and dairy, single-source spices, and CT-grown produce.
Choose your flavors or be surprised!
Handmade and fresh, especially for you.
With a new, artfully curated menu each month.
Just in time for the weekend.
Delivered straight to your door.
Shipped on the second or last Thursday of every month (your choice!).
Baked Once.
Then, Gone Forever.
A New Menu
Every Month
Discover your new favorite flavor each month
January 2026 Menu
Specialty Cookies
Made with the highest quality ingredients. Joy without the guilt.
Ship Date: January 16th or 30th, 2026
Ship date is based on your selected preference. Winter is in full swing, but these cookies will keep you cozy!
Belgian Milk Chocolate
Luxuriously creamy. You’ll taste luscious Belgian milk chocolate, semi-sweet chocolate chips, creamy butter, and organic Madagascar vanilla beans.
Dark Chocolate S'mores
Valrhona chocolate cookie mixed with organic graham crackers and topped with a puffy scratch made vanilla bean marshmallow. Organic agave syrup and vanilla beans make for a special marshmallow. You'll taste dark, rich cocoa, sweet vanilla, and a touch of molasses from the graham crackers.
Ultimate PB&J
An Evjoy twist on a classic! This cookie is packed with scratch-made peanut butter praline and organic strawberry jam in a brown butter cookie base. You'll taste nuttiness, sweet, salty, and fruity goodness.
Peppermint Bark
Scratch-made Belgian dark chocolate peppermint bark shards on a brown butter cookie. Enough said.
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Sweet, decadent, sticky... all the things that make sticky toffee pudding amazing in a portable bite. You'll taste rich date infused toffee and toasted walnuts.
Specialty Surprise Flavor
A cookie to celebrate the best of the season.
Begin
Your
Ritual
BAKED FROM SCRATCH
Shop Our Seasonal Box
COMING SOON!
Not ready to commit to a subscription? Don't worry, we've all been there. Enjoy our cookies with a curated seasonal box. Details coming soon.
What is a
Specialty Cookie?
.png)
Baked clean, baked local
No preservatives or food additives ever! Just pure, delicious joy.
One of a kind
Discover unique twists on classic favorites, international flavor profiles, and uncommon luxury ingredients. Each menu is thoughtfully curated to maximize joy. And, every recipe is our own.
Artisanal
ingredients
Crafted with the best of the best: organic flour, organic eggs, unrefined organic sugar, single-source spices, and farm-fresh produce.
Entirely from scratch
Every cookie is a true labor of love. Every topping, filling, and dough is made in-house using our own recipes. No hidden ingredients here.
Evelyn is on a mission to create “true deliciousness”.
This means bringing the joy of dessert to pure, incredible, and whole ingredients. It also means paying attention to every last detail to tap into dessert’s best superpower: creating a bite so delicious it melts the world away.
That’s why, after 19 years of baking, she partnered with her brother to build a commercial kitchen in his luxury auto salon. A bit unconventional, but the perfect opportunity to create a family-owned and operated business that truly cares about what it puts out into the world.
MEET
THE
BAKER
Evelyn Castro
Be the First to Know
From our kitchen to your tastebuds.
80 Prindle Rd., West Haven, CT 06516